Ronan O’Gara Slams World Rugby’s 20-Minute Red Card Proposal
La Rochelle head coach Ronan O’Gara has expressed his frustration with World Rugby’s latest proposal, sharply criticizing the governing body’s consideration of the 20-minute red card rule. The proposed law, currently being trialed in the Rugby Championship and U20 Championship, would allow teams to replace a player who has been sent off after 20 minutes, effectively reducing the impact of a red card.
O’Gara, a prominent figure in the sport, did not hold back, describing the idea as “nonsense” during his appearance on Off The Ball. His stance echoes the growing opposition, with both Irish Rugby and France also firmly against the move.
This proposal has sparked widespread debate, as many believe it undermines the deterrent effect of red cards in maintaining discipline on the field. O’Gara’s criticism adds fuel to the conversation, highlighting the potential impact this rule could have on the integrity of the game.
As the rugby world waits for further developments, it’s clear that not all stakeholders are on board with these changes, raising questions about the future direction of the sport’s regulations.
“My thoughts would be strong, the 20-minute red card is nonsense,” O’Gara said.
“I don’t see where it fits into the game.”
“We’re always trying to learn how to make the game better. A red card is a serious act of foul play. If it’s a serious act of foul play, there’s no place in the game for 20 minutes [red cards].
“It’s quite simple if it warrants a red card and the criteria and process around awarding a red card is quite strict – but nowadays is strict the right word to use because there’s a difference of opinion on nearly every single rule in the game of rugby and a different perception in terms of headshots and height and intent.
“A 20-minute red card I think it opens the door, especially for player safety, we could be re-entering dangerous territory again.”
